5 Comments
User's avatar
Quiet Operator's avatar

A check I use before acting on feedback is to ask for one recent, specific example. If the person can name the moment, it is usually information about a real pattern. If they cannot, I hold it lightly and watch for a second source before changing anything. It keeps the sting from deciding what I do next.

Nikki Butler's avatar

This has really got me thinking about how early we learn to treat feedback as a verdict on who we are! Especially when it comes from someone in authority. I spent years taking comments about needing to try harder as proof that I wasn't doing enough, rather than questioning whether the expectations or the way I was being taught actually worked for me. And goodness, that habit doesn't magically disappear when you leave school! I really like the idea of teaching people to be curious about feedback rather than automatically accepting it as fact. Although I suspect unlearning that habit might take a fair bit of practice!

Nancy Chu's avatar

the reframe that feedback tells you about the giver's preferences, not a verdict on you, is one of the few feedback models i've seen actually change how someone shows up in their next 1:1, i send a version of this to clients all the time

Matt Doan's avatar

“It is about them, not you” works on praise too. Somebody cheering your 60-hour weeks is telling you what they like.

Kathy Kushinsky's avatar

One other thing to think about is asking the second question when someone provides feedback. Whether it's in a formal review or annectdotal feedback that's come up in conversation, treating it as a data point or information is important. In the moment, respond wiht curiosity. My go to is "Tell me more". This provides greater context for that feedback. My second question generally is what would a more successful approach look like? You're not agreeing or disagreeing. You're allowing hte person to be heard and you have the opportunity to gain more insight. It could be that they are responding out of context, or that you both see things differently - and that's OK. A second thing that can be helpful is to ask your trusted advisors or personal board, their perspective on the feedback. If there is a strong "Truth Teller" in your circle, ask them. Sometimes we don't see behaviors in the same way others do.